Identifying Competitive Moats within Managed Service Providers

Identifying Competitive Moats within Managed Service Providers

December 16, 2024
December 16, 2024

Share

Image of Mark Skinner

Mark Skinner

Manager

The demand for enterprise technology continues to surge, fueled by the need for businesses to stay competitive and efficient in an increasingly digital landscape. Managed Service Providers (MSPs) are at the forefront of this evolution, offering a range of IT services that alleviate the complexities of managing and maintaining technology infrastructure within an organization. The constant increase in cybersecurity risks emphasizes the crucial role of MSPs in protecting businesses against threats and ensuring secure, continuous operations. 


For companies that want to avoid the IT “talent wars,” MSPs provide essential technology expertise which allows businesses to maintain focus on their core competencies. Thus, in this challenging landscape, it’s essential to identify the competitive moats that make an MSP stand out. Leveraging our deep experience in evaluating and working alongside MSPs, Stax has several key observations and insights to help private equity investors in identifying these moats. 

Challenges in Identifying Competitive Moats

Amid the many opportunities within the MSP space, identifying what differentiates providers remains a significant challenge for investors. In a crowded market, with nearly 40,000 MSPs—and many offering similar services—it can be difficult to assess which ones have the strongest growth potential. 


Additionally, the rapid pace of technological advancement requires constant service updates, further complicating the ability to maintain a competitive edge. Combined with the diverse needs of clients across various industries and organizations, this further complicates determining which MSPs are best positioned to thrive. 

Pathways to Building Competitive Moats

While the landscape may be crowded, several pathways allow MSPs to build strong competitive moats that help them stand out from their peers: 

Building Regulatory Insight

One of the most critical avenues for MSP differentiation is deep expertise in regulatory compliance. This expertise transforms an MSP from a general IT provider into a trusted partner for enterprise clients—especially in highly regulated industries. MSPs that can help businesses navigate complex regulations build credibility and trust—key factors in client acquisition and retention.


For instance, an MSP with expertise in the following regulations demonstrates a clear competitive advantage over undifferentiated generalists:


  • HIPAA: Protects patient health information in healthcare settings. 
  • PCI DSS: Regulates secure credit card transactions for retail and financial sectors. 
  • CMMC: Sets cybersecurity standards for defense contractors. 
  • GDPR: Governs personal data protection in the EU. 
  • CCPA: Enhances privacy rights for California residents. 


By helping clients develop compliance strategies that align with these regulations, MSPs become indispensable, particularly those operating in regulated industries like healthcare, finance, or government. 

Verticalized Configuration

Another strong differentiator is vertical specialization. MSPs that develop tailored solutions for specific verticals can build a deeper understanding of both the regulatory and technological challenges faced by clients in those sectors. Verticalization requires expertise essential for establishing credibility with clients, as well as a deep understanding of the vertical to help clients leverage technology-driven opportunities. 


The advantages of a verticalized approach for MSPs are numerous: 


  • Expertise: Verticalized MSPs stand apart from generalists as subject matter experts, able to add value to client systems and processes. 
  • Speed: MSPs can implement time-tested playbooks that streamline service delivery and reduce training time for staff. 
  • Cost-effectiveness: Aligning services with specific industry requirements improves profitability and reduces wasted resources of attempting unprofitable projects. 
  • Talent: Vertical specialization enables MSPs to attract talent that want to be on the forefront of industry practice. 
  • Premium services: Delivering high-value, industry-specific solutions can command higher prices, enhancing overall profitability and perceived value. 
  • Referrals: With a strong reputation in a specific industry, verticalized MSPs can more easily tap into professional networks and industry associations, leading to increased organic growth. 


For example, with the upcoming CMMC (Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification) compliance requirements, MSPs that specialize in defense contracting will have a significant advantage in guiding clients to meet these new standards. 


However, building this level of expertise takes time, which is why many MSPs turn to M&A to quickly expand their capabilities and break into new sectors. 

What We’re Seeing

Verticalization is a process that takes significant time to develop organically. At Stax, we’re seeing many MSPs actively pursuing M&A strategies to accelerate their expertise and establish footholds in new industries. This trend creates ample opportunities for investors seeking differentiated MSPs, especially those positioned for growth in regulated sectors. 



Additionally, with newer CMMC regulations set to take effect, MSPs that are well-versed in compliance are poised to win new clients in need of guidance through these changes. 

The Role of Stax

For both investors and MSPs, Stax plays a pivotal role in identifying and building competitive moats. We help investors pinpoint MSPs that have developed robust moats, whether through regulatory expertise, vertical specialization, or technological capabilities. Our team conducts thorough assessments of market positioning, client satisfaction, and service offerings to inform investment decisions, ensuring that investors back the MSPs with the greatest growth potential. 



Stax also partners with MSPs directly, offering strategic guidance to help them scale operations efficiently. This includes identifying acquisition opportunities that complement existing capabilities and extend market reach. Our goal is to help MSPs capitalize on their strengths while expanding their service offerings in ways that enhance profitability and competitiveness. 

Conclusion

MSPs operate in a dynamic environment shaped by evolving technology, cybersecurity concerns, and stringent regulatory demands. Differentiation through regulatory expertise, vertical specialization, and tailored service offerings is essential for standing out in a crowded market. 


By working with Stax, investors and MSPs alike can identify and build on these competitive moats, fostering growth and operational excellence. Our partnerships with MSPs have provided us with valuable experience to help drive growth and create value through actionable insights.  To learn more about Stax and our expertise, visit www.stax.com or click here to contact us directly. 

Read More

Increasing PE Interest Upstream: Stax Oil & Gas Software Market Update
By Palash Misra May 27, 2025
As prices decline and cost pressures rise, Oil & Gas operators are doubling down on digital tools to stay competitive. Read about Stax Managing Director Palash Misra's insights here.
8 Questions for PE Investors Eyeing the Maritime Data Industry
By Andrew Keller May 23, 2025
Stax Director Andrew Keller shares eight invaluable questions that private equity investors need to ask before considering an investment in the Maritime market. Click here to read more.
What 2025 Is Demanding from PE: 9 Takeaways from the PE NY Forum
By Paul Edwards May 20, 2025
Nine critical insights shaping private equity in 2025 from the 13th Annual PE New York Forum—including strategic exits, secondaries, sector shifts, AI integration, and a growing urgency to act in uncertain times. Click to learn more.
The New Standard of Buy-side Diligence: Embedding Value Creation
By Vince Zosa May 16, 2025
As investors seek strong conviction on near term value creation during due diligence, Vince Zosa shares 5 key value levers that top-performing investors are scrutinizing from day one. Read more.
Private Equity's Next Chapter: From Arbitrage to Enduring Impact
May 15, 2025
Stax CEO Jayson Traxler shares why leading PE firms are shifting from financial engineering to value creation—and how Stax partners with investors to drive lasting impact. Read more.
Stax Advises Tenzing on Investment in ScreenCloud, a Cloud Digital Signage Leader
May 12, 2025
Stax congratulates Tenzing on its recent strategic investment in ScreenCloud, a global leader in cloud digital signage solutions. Click here to read more about the deal.
Show More