Medicare Advantage’s Growing Share of the Market

Medicare Advantage’s Growing Share of the Market

Yiwei Jiang • April 1, 2024
Yiwei Jiang • April 1, 2024

Share

Key Findings

  • Medicare Advantage has been steadily gaining share of enrollments among the rising Medicare-eligible population (versus traditional Medicare). 
  • While tech-enabled insurers within Medicare Advantage have seen rapid growth in the past few years, they’ve only scratched the surface in terms of market share (with only ~1.5% of current Medicare Advantage enrollments). 
  • Stax expects these players to continue to see rapid growth in the coming years, given their value proposition of enhanced agility, improved member experiences, and lower thresholds for value-based care (VBC) / risk-sharing agreements. 
  • Incumbents and other Medicare Advantage insurers are actively seeking ways to add/incorporate technology solutions to their offerings to stay competitive and better align to demand preferences. 

Increasing Enrollment in Medicare Advantage

The Medicare-eligible population is increasingly enrolling in Medicare Advantage for the combination of richer benefits (e.g., dental, vision, hearing), lower member costs, and more inclusive plans. Government-funded incentives, such as bonus payments for high-star rating plans, also continue to promote Medicare Advantage. 


The graph below illustrates the gradual but substantial shift to Medicare Advantage over the past several years. Given the steady progression of enrollment rates, alongside the aforementioned factors, we expect this trend to continue for the foreseeable future. 

Bar chart depicting national medicare enrollment by type, hospital/medical plan from 2016-2020 (number of enrollments).

Advantages of Tech-Enabled Payors

Among Medicare Advantage plans, tech-enabled insurers have been gaining traction, and increased their market share by more than 2x over the past 3 years. 

A list of tech-enabled insurers, with logos
Chart describing the market share of tech-enabled companies from 2017-2023.

From Stax’s perspective, tech-enabled payors have some key advantages—such as customer experience, value-based care, and organizational agility—likely to continue driving their growth:

  • Emerging tech-enabled players can give their customer service representatives more autonomy over resolving issues with a customer due to their smaller, leaner nature. Further, tech platforms can enable instant visibility to all customer reps. In addition, customer service reps can seamlessly collaborate across departments to resolve a variety of issues. 


  • Tech-enabled players have an inherently stronger value proposition for risk-sharing agreements, like VBC, compared to incumbents who require a minimum threshold. Startups pitch lower thresholds necessary for value-based care in order to get in the door with providers, offering a higher fee schedule with less patients.  

Conclusion

Stax adapts to changing trends every day to provide our clients with current and actionable insights that aid in value creation. To learn more about Stax, visit www.stax.com or contact us here

Image of Yiwei Jiang

Yiwei Jiang

Senior Consultant

Read More

The MSP Landscape: Ripe for Consolidation, Expansion, and Expertise-Led Differentiation
By Tyler Veit, Tyler Michaels, Luke Scheibel, & Yiwei Jiang October 28, 2025
The MSP sector offers durable growth through recurring revenues, industry-specific specialization, and ecosystem partnerships—while AI introduces new opportunities. Read more.
Phil Dunne Featured on The Consulting Report's Podcast: Top Consultant
By Phil Dunne October 23, 2025
Stax Managing Director Phil Dunne recently joined the Top Consultant podcast hosted by The Consulting Report, to discuss his career and Grant Thornton Stax. Listen to the show here.
Grant Thornton Stax Honored with Prestigious OnCon Icon Top 100 Award
October 22, 2025
Grant Thornton Stax has been awarded the esteemed OnCon Icon Top 100 award for its excellence in marketing. Click here to read about the award.
Grant Thornton Stax Supports TrustArc Acquisition by Main Capital Partners​
October 22, 2025
Grant Thornton Stax recently supported TrustArc, a leading provider of privacy compliance and data protection solutions, on its acquisition by Main Capital Partners. Read more here.
Six Cybersecurity Themes Private Equity Investors Should Know Leaving 2025
By Marissa Licursi, Tyler Michaels, & Yiwei Jiang October 20, 2025
Grant Thornton Stax has compiled this report outlining several key investment themes, based on our prior work with cybersecurity assets throughout 2025 to date. Read more here.
Robert Lytle & Phil Dunne Named Top 25 PE Consultants & Leaders of 2025
By Robert Lytle & Phil Dunne October 20, 2025
Robert Lytle and Phil Dunne were named amongst The Top 25 Private Equity Consultants and Leaders of 2025. Click here to read more about the list and The Consulting Report.
Show More